After Amanda Marcotte Calling Hallmark’s Christmas films “fascist propaganda,” the co-hosts of “Fox & Friends” accused Salon’s senior political editor of attacking “American values.”
The host trio took issue with Marcotte’s op-ed earlier this week, which criticized the Hallmark Channel for applying a white, Christian, and heteronormative worldview in its cinematic canon. The hosts often brought in Hallmark frontman Dean Cain, who accused Marcotte of waging a war on Christmas. In truth, she had advocated for diversity in the network’s vacation programming.
Responding to a controversy over Hallmark pulling commercials promoting Zola wedding company which showed a lesbian couple kissing, Marcotte criticized the network for claiming it was “committed to diversity and inclusion”.
“Discovering this year’s Christmas film program is like a journey through a strange valley of heteronormative whiteness with shiny, dried-up teeth, with only a few symbolic films with colored characters. It’s like watching “The Stepford Wives”, only scarier because the evil plot to replace normal people with robots is never actually revealed, “Marcotte wrote. Even in Nazi Germany, the majority of films endorsed by Nazi Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels were breakout and light-hearted films, with a Hallmark film-style emphasis on the importance of ‘normalcy’. “
Ultimately, there’s probably no way to reconcile the pretense of believing in ‘diversity’ with the fascist impulse that drives the current crop of Hallmark films, which still focus on these frankly MAGA-style ideas. on what constitutes the “real” America, “Marcotte added. “The best Hallmark can do is symbolic ‘diversity’ that erases most of what makes people truly diverse. Their money comes from selling a vision of America that increasingly authoritarian conservatives wish to believe once existed and can be restored again – an America that excludes most of a nation. increasingly urban, racially diverse cosmopolitan.
The Fox & Friends hosts called on Cain, who is best known for his portrayal of Superman in the short-lived ABC series “Lois & Clark”, to respond to Marcotte’s criticism. Cain, who co-hosted Ed Henry as the “Hallmark heartthrob,” called these opinions not only “crazy” but also “ridiculous”.
“It’s really terrifying to wake up on Boxing Day to find Santa Claus is a Nazi,” Cain said. “It was so ridiculous I thought it was a terrible parody of Adam Schiff. Then I went to read it, and it’s crazy. (Marcotte didn’t call Santa a Nazi in his article. .)
Cain further claimed that “if you want to know who the fascist is, look who wrote the article”, alleging that Marcotte “told you what you should believe” and “how society should be” when she didn ‘called the network only to reflect the diversity of its own audience.
“It is just completely wrong to say that this is Nazi propaganda or fascist propaganda,” Cain said. “The Hallmark Channel is the furthest thing from that.”
The co-hosts then read an excerpt from a statement by Salon editor-in-chief Erin Keane, which encouraged viewers to “appreciate your vacation fare, but with a critical eye.”
“We recommend anyone interested in this article to come to the Show and read it for yourself,” Keane said in the full release. “While many people watch the empty Hallmark Channel quilts for fun, it’s important to understand how false nostalgia works and how it can be used as a weapon to marginalize people as ‘different’ from being LGBTQ, non-white, or being women with career ambitions. “
Cain shook his head as the hosts read the quote before accusing Salon of attacking Christmas, a holiday that was marked in numerous articles on his website.
“They don’t say anything that means anything,” Cain said. “It’s just a faceless attack on Christmas and love. These are the enemies. They hate Hallmark. I’m sure they hate Fox News.
“It’s a pathetic attack on American cultural values and institutions,” Pavlich said.
However, the segment ignored the fact that Marcotte’s words came in response to a right-wing lobbying campaign, which demanded Hallmark remove an ad showing a lesbian couple kissing. The network withdrew the ad, saying it was against its policy of running ads featuring “overt public displays of affection,” which Marcotte said was hypocritical given its own holiday programming.
His comment further criticized the network for betraying its “commitment to diversity” by presenting holiday programming, which is almost entirely white.
“It is essential to be aware of the role that Hallmark films actually play in our society,” Marcotte wrote. “The very fact that they are presented as harmless fluff makes it all the more insidious how they work to uphold very narrow, white, heteronormative, sexist, provincial ideas of what constitutes ‘normal’.”